Old-Timey Flights

Although many of my previous posts have been for ambitious vacations, in the continued economic downturn it may be more realistic to try to go somewhere closer and more affordable. Additionally, having been inundated by iProducts and all sorts of other electronic society, I'd like to get away from all that without going full-on Amish. I've been thinking either Williamsburg, Virginia or Branson, Missouri. Both are reasonably short flights from LaGuardia in NYC and neither should cost too much while there. Since I plan on traveling alone I'm thinking Williamsburg is probably better for me but if you think otherwise please let me know why. Finally, as always, which airlines would you choose for each destination?